Updated
What is actually known about each one
Three kinds of mushroom on one site: the ones sold for an effect, the ones that are illegal nearly everywhere and carry a serious trial record anyway, and the ones you cook. Every claim here is set against the public trial register and the indexed literature, and says which of the two it came from.
Sold for an effect
Twenty-five mushrooms people take for something, each one placed by how far the research has actually got: repeated trials in people, a first trial, a trial still running, laboratory work, or tradition alone.
Magic mushrooms
The species people mean, the compound the trials are actually about, where the law stands, and the brown mushrooms that have killed people who were looking for these.
What they are like to eat
Taste, texture and how each one is cooked — and the few that must be cooked a particular way or not eaten at all.
Everything, as it comes in
ReishiGanoderma lucidumRepeated trialsits best-evidenced use is cancer, supportive and adjuvant
CordycepsCordyceps militarisRepeated trialsits best-evidenced use is kidney
ShiitakeLentinula edodesRepeated trialsits best-evidenced use is cancer, supportive and adjuvant
AntrodiaTaiwanofungus camphoratusRepeated trialsits best-evidenced use is cancer, supportive and adjuvant
Turkey tailTrametes versicolorRepeated trialsits best-evidenced use is cancer, supportive and adjuvant
Lion's maneHericium erinaceusRepeated trialsits best-evidenced use is memory and focus
Oyster mushroomPleurotus ostreatusRepeated trialsits best-evidenced use is mood and anxiety
Royal sun agaricAgaricus subrufescensRepeated trialsits best-evidenced use is wound healing
AgarikonFomitopsis officinalisRepeated trialsits best-evidenced use is viral infection
MaitakeGrifola frondosaA first trialits best-evidenced use is cancer, supportive and adjuvant
Button mushroomAgaricus bisporusA first trialits best-evidenced use is nutrition
Zhu lingPolyporus umbellatusA first trialits best-evidenced use is liver
Cauliflower fungusSparassis crispaA first trialits best-evidenced use is skin
ChagaInonotus obliquusBeing tested nowits best-evidenced use is sleep
TremellaTremella fuciformisBeing tested nowits best-evidenced use is memory and focus
King oysterPleurotus eryngiiBeing tested now
EnokiFlammulina velutipesLaboratory workits best-evidenced use is wound healing
Wood earAuricularia auricula-judaeLaboratory workits best-evidenced use is wound healing
ShimejiHypsizygus marmoreusLaboratory workits best-evidenced use is wound healing
Birch polyporeFomitopsis betulinaLaboratory workits best-evidenced use is wound healing
Artist's conkGanoderma applanatumLaboratory workits best-evidenced use is wound healing
Chicken of the woodsLaetiporus sulphureusLaboratory workits best-evidenced use is wound healing
MorelMorchella esculentaLaboratory workits best-evidenced use is wound healing
Psilocybe cubensisPsilocybe cubensisMagic mushroomsgolden teacher, cubes, San Isidro
Liberty capPsilocybe semilanceataMagic mushroomsliberty cap, witch's hat
Wavy capPsilocybe cyanescensMagic mushroomswavy cap
Flying saucerPsilocybe azurescensMagic mushroomsflying saucer, azzies
Psilocybe mexicanaPsilocybe mexicanaMagic mushroomsteonanácatl, pajaritos
Blue meaniePanaeolus cyanescensMagic mushroomsblue meanie, Copelandia
Psilocybe baeocystisPsilocybe baeocystisMagic mushroomsbottle cap, knobby tops
Fly agaricAmanita muscariaMagic mushroomsfly agaric, fly amanita
Laughing gymGymnopilus junoniusMagic mushroomslaughing gym, spectacular rustgill
Lion's maneHericium erinaceusWhat they are like to eatMild and faintly sweet, often compared to crab or scallop — the comparison is about texture as much as flavour.
ReishiGanoderma lucidumWhat they are like to eatWoody and genuinely bitter. Nobody eats reishi for pleasure.
CordycepsCordyceps militarisWhat they are like to eatMild, slightly nutty, a little savoury.
ChagaInonotus obliquusWhat they are like to eatDark, faintly vanilla, closer to a weak coffee than to a mushroom.
Turkey tailTrametes versicolorWhat they are like to eatAlmost none. It is thin, leathery and inedible as food.
MaitakeGrifola frondosaWhat they are like to eatDeeply savoury and peppery, one of the best-flavoured mushrooms there is.
ShiitakeLentinula edodesWhat they are like to eatStrongly savoury, almost meaty; dried ones are far more intense than fresh.
TremellaTremella fuciformisWhat they are like to eatVirtually none — it takes on whatever it is cooked in.
Royal sun agaricAgaricus subrufescensWhat they are like to eatSweet and almond-like, which is where 'almond mushroom' comes from.
Oyster mushroomPleurotus ostreatusWhat they are like to eatMild, a little aniseed when very fresh.
EnokiFlammulina velutipesWhat they are like to eatClean, mild, slightly fruity.
King oysterPleurotus eryngiiWhat they are like to eatMild and sweet, with the thickest stem of any cultivated mushroom.
Zhu lingPolyporus umbellatusWhat they are like to eatBitter and medicinal.
AntrodiaTaiwanofungus camphoratusWhat they are like to eatIntensely bitter.
Wood earAuricularia auricula-judaeWhat they are like to eatAlmost none. It is eaten for its texture, which is crunchy and gelatinous at the same time.
Cauliflower fungusSparassis crispaWhat they are like to eatMild, nutty and faintly almond.
ShimejiHypsizygus marmoreusWhat they are like to eatBitter raw, nutty and sweet once cooked. The change is dramatic.
Birch polyporeFomitopsis betulinaWhat they are like to eatBitter, and tough as cork.
AgarikonFomitopsis officinalisWhat they are like to eatExtremely bitter — the old name 'quinine conk' is about the taste.
Artist's conkGanoderma applanatumWhat they are like to eatWoody, no culinary value.
Chicken of the woodsLaetiporus sulphureusWhat they are like to eatMild, lemony, with a texture genuinely close to chicken breast when young.
MorelMorchella esculentaWhat they are like to eatDeep, dark and smoky — among the most prized flavours in European cooking.
Button mushroomAgaricus bisporusWhat they are like to eatMild and familiar raw; properly savoury once browned. Cremini and portobello are the same species left to grow on and darken.